Building a scalable feature flagging service

Wed Jul 24 2024

By decoupling feature management from code deployment, feature flags enable quick changes and experimentation without the need for complex branching strategies or risky deployments.

Feature flags, also known as feature toggles or switches, act as a safety net for your software. They allow you to wrap new features in conditional statements, giving you the ability to turn them on or off as needed. This level of control is invaluable when it comes to testing in production, performing A/B tests, or gradually rolling out features to specific user segments.

Understanding feature flags and their importance

At their core, feature flags are simple conditional statements that determine whether a feature should be executed or bypassed. By wrapping new code in these flags, you can control its visibility and behavior without modifying the underlying codebase. This separation of concerns is what makes feature flags so powerful.

One of the key benefits of using a feature flag service is the ability to decouple feature management from code deployment. Instead of relying on long-lived feature branches or complex merging strategies, you can safely deploy new code to production while keeping it hidden behind a flag. This allows you to continuously integrate and deploy, reducing the risk of merge conflicts and enabling faster iteration cycles.

Feature flags also support various rollout strategies, giving you fine-grained control over how new features are introduced to your users. For example:

  • Phased rollouts: Gradually release a feature to a increasing percentage of users, monitoring for any issues along the way.

  • Targeted releases: Enable a feature for specific user segments, such as beta testers or premium customers.

  • A/B testing: Randomly assign users to different variations of a feature to measure its impact on key metrics.

By leveraging these strategies, you can gather valuable feedback, mitigate risks, and make data-driven decisions about your product development.

Architecting a scalable feature flag service

Designing a scalable feature flag service requires a 'dumb server, smart client' architecture. This approach offloads flag evaluation to the client, minimizing server load. The server simply maintains and delivers a JSON file describing the feature flags and rules.

Leveraging Content Delivery Networks (CDNs) is crucial for handling requests efficiently. CDNs serve requests close to the client's origin, reducing latency and server burden. This allows the feature flag service to scale seamlessly without significant infrastructure costs.

Balancing evaluation latency and update latency is key to optimal performance. Evaluation latency refers to the time taken for a client to determine the applicable flag value. Update latency is the time required for updated rules to reach the client. Prioritizing fast evaluations may result in slower updates, but this trade-off is often acceptable to ensure a responsive user experience.

Client SDKs play a vital role in the 'dumb server, smart client' model. They handle the logic for downloading and parsing the feature flag JSON file. However, this approach requires significant development effort and regular updates to support new targeting rules.

Setting appropriate polling frequencies and cache time-to-live (TTL) helps manage update latency. Clients periodically poll the server for updated flag configurations, while caching reduces the need for frequent server requests. Finding the right balance between polling frequency and cache TTL ensures timely flag updates without overloading the server.

Monitoring and analytics are essential for a robust feature flag service. Tracking flag usage, performance metrics, and user behavior provides valuable insights for decision-making. This data helps optimize flag configurations, identify issues, and measure the impact of feature releases.

As the feature flag service scales, maintaining a clean and organized flag management system becomes crucial. Regularly reviewing and removing unused flags prevents technical debt and keeps the system manageable. Establishing clear processes for flag creation, modification, and retirement ensures a smooth workflow and reduces the risk of errors.

Implementing feature flags in your codebase

Implementing feature flags in your codebase involves wrapping new features in conditional statements. This allows you to easily toggle features on and off without modifying the underlying code. By using if/else statements or similar constructs, you can control the execution flow based on the flag's status.

To manage feature flags effectively, create a configuration file that defines and organizes them. This file acts as a central repository for flag definitions, making it easy to update and maintain flag states. You can store the configuration file in a format like JSON or YAML, which can be easily parsed by your application.

When implementing feature flags, consider the different types of toggles you may need:

  • Release toggles: Control the rollout of new features to users

  • Experiment toggles: Enable A/B testing and experimentation

  • Ops toggles: Provide operational control over system behavior

  • Permissioning toggles: Manage user access to specific features

Each type of toggle serves a distinct purpose in your feature flagging strategy. Release toggles help you gradually introduce new functionality, while experiment toggles facilitate data-driven decision-making. Ops toggles give you control over system behavior in real-time, and permissioning toggles ensure users have access to the right features based on their roles or permissions.

To integrate feature flags seamlessly into your feature flag service, use client-side SDKs or libraries that abstract the flag evaluation logic. These SDKs handle the communication with the feature flag service, retrieving the latest flag configurations and evaluating them based on user attributes or other criteria. This approach keeps your application code clean and focused on business logic.

When working with feature flags, it's crucial to maintain a clean and organized codebase. Regularly review and remove flags that are no longer needed to prevent technical debt. Use descriptive names for your flags to make their purpose clear, and consider using naming conventions to differentiate between different types of toggles. Creating, configuring, and deploying feature flags in production environments is a crucial aspect of managing a feature flag service. You'll need to define the flags, set their initial states, and associate them with specific features in your codebase. Once configured, deploy the flags to your production environment, ensuring they're accessible to your application.

Monitoring flag performance and collecting analytics is essential for making informed decisions about your feature releases. Track key metrics like user engagement, conversion rates, and performance to understand how your features are performing. Use this data to optimize your feature rollouts and make data-driven decisions.

Regularly retiring flags that are no longer needed is important to prevent technical debt and maintain system cleanliness. Once a feature is fully released and stable, remove the associated flag from your codebase and configuration. This helps keep your feature flag service manageable and reduces the risk of unexpected behavior.

When managing a feature flag service, consider the following best practices:

  • Keep flag names descriptive and consistent

  • Use a centralized configuration store for easy management

  • Implement access controls to prevent unauthorized changes

  • Regularly review and clean up unused flags

  • Monitor flag usage and performance to identify issues early

By following these practices and carefully managing the lifecycle of your feature flags, you can ensure a smooth and effective feature release process. A well-managed feature flag service enables you to deliver new features with confidence, while minimizing risk and maximizing the value to your users.

Best practices for scaling feature flag services

To effectively scale feature flag services, consider using distributed toggle configuration with hierarchical key-value stores like Zookeeper, etcd, or Consul. These specialized services form a distributed cluster, providing a shared source of configuration for all nodes. Configuration changes are dynamically propagated to the entire fleet.

Override configurations allow for per-request flag modifications using special cookies, query parameters, or HTTP headers. This approach enables targeted testing and reduces the risk of accidentally leaving overrides in place. However, be cautious of the potential for curious or malicious users to modify toggle states themselves.

Improve system visibility by exposing current feature toggle configurations through metadata API endpoints. This practice allows developers, testers, and operators to easily determine the state of toggle configurations across environments. Embedding build/version numbers into deployed artifacts further enhances transparency.

Prefer static configuration managed through source control and re-deployments when possible. This approach offers the benefits of infrastructure as code, allowing toggle configuration to coexist with the codebase and move through the Continuous Delivery pipeline consistently. Static configuration simplifies testing and enables easy recreation of previous releases.

For more dynamic scenarios, consider parameterized toggle configuration using command-line arguments or environment variables. This approach allows for re-configuration without rebuilding the application, although it may require process restarts. Toggle configuration files offer another option, enabling flag re-configuration by modifying the file rather than rebuilding code.

As feature flag usage grows, moving toggle configuration into a centralized store, such as an existing application database, becomes advantageous. Accompanied by an admin UI, this approach simplifies flag management and ensures consistency across a fleet of servers. However, be mindful of the potential complexity introduced by feature flags and strive to minimize toggle points.

Request a demo

Statsig's experts are on standby to answer any questions about experimentation at your organization.
request a demo cta image

Build fast?

Subscribe to Scaling Down: Our newsletter on building at startup-speed.

Try Statsig Today

Get started for free. Add your whole team!
We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.
Privacy Policy